Monday, April 21, 2008

RANDOM QUESTION OF THE DAY




Rumor has it that Kanye asked Alexis for her engagement ring back. Do you think that she should return it or do you consider it a gift? Or, should she only return the ring if the break up was her fault?

Putting emotions aside, I believe that unless an engagement ring is given on a holiday or birthday (and thus a "gift"), then the ring should be returned if the engagement is broken.


Source

9 comments:

PCD (Pretty Circle Drawer) said...

i REALLY don't know...never thought about it. on one hand, its a gift because it was given. but on the other, it was given with an expected outcome...so if that outcome doesn't happen....geesh! that's a toughie....don't make a girl choose when it has ANYTHING to do with diamonds!!! you might draw back a nub!

Grown Woman said...

LMBPAO--this issue was hotly debated on the radio this morning

Eb the Celeb said...

I want to know why he broke off the engagement?

i definitely think each circumstance is different though... but if she is the reason for the break-up she should definitely give it back...

if he was unsure than that's his own fault and I'm keeping it

TravelDiva said...

For regular guys - If it was mutual, then I'd say give it back. But if it was his fault, then she should keep it.

For Kanye - he's rich--it's not like he needs the money. That's just spite. LOL.

Smarty Jones said...

LoL @ all of ya'll. Of course you knew he'd ask for the ring back, he's Kanye West, the King of Petty!
I'm not sure how I feel about asking for the ring back because I am not completely sold on the marriage thing.
I believe if you're going to do it, it should be treated like a contract. In fact, at the time of engagement, a contract should be drawn up to kill any complications that may arise from termination of the relation-shit.
That way, there aren't any surprises. And just because he asked for it doesn't mean she has to give it back. Possession is nine-tenths of the law.
She could always do what Jawn Murray says Tracey Edmonds did. According to him, she said she ain't giving the ring back and she's been wearing it!

Grown Woman said...

LOL on Tracey Edmonds still wearing her engagement ring. I wouldn't do that. If I kept the ring, I'd pawn it or something.

Louis and Nadja said...

One of my friends sold hers and went to the Dominican Republic.

TravelDiva said...

Now THAT is a good idea. Go on a vacay with it. LOL. But Kanyeezy might take her to court!

Still_Pocahontaz said...

He wouldnt get shyt back...aint nothing cool about being an indian giver...if he really want it back he can take her on Judge Judy